B
Sullivan County, Missouri

John P. Butler

born 1846 · documented in 2 county histories

The original biography

In the books' own words, not ours, with obvious scanning errors fixed. The later printing (1898) is folded below the first. Families often supplied these stories to the publisher, so check key dates.

Born 1846

From History of Adair, Sullivan, Putnam and Schuyler Counties, Missouri (1888), The history of the bench and bar of Missouri : With reminiscences of the prominent lawyers of the past, and a record of the law's leaders of the present (1898)

As printed in 1888

John P. Butler was born near Clinton, Allegheny Co., Penn., Jetober 18, 1846. His great-grandfather, George Butler, same to America some years prior to the war of the Revolution, und settled in the State of Pennsylvania, on the Delaware River, near the city of Philadelphia. His wife was a Miss Sarah Davis, a native of Wales, and whose three brothers were sho founders of the Baptist Church in that. country. In the stirring scenes incident to the war of independence Mr. Butler took an active part as a soldier in the continental army. He yad numerous sons and daughters, among whom were to John Danmead; Rebecca, married to Jesse Forker; Peggy, married to John Smith; Nancy, married to Ben Kline; Raehel, married to a man named Kinney, and two other Janghters whose names are now unknown, His sons were Simon, Abia, George and Ben. His eldest son, Simon, was born in 1758,

Polly, married and afterward married Charity Lamberson, and died in Beaver County, Penn., in 1850, ‘The next oldest was Abia, born in L708, — who afterward married Jane Boll, and died in Lawrence County, Penn., in 1871. George Butler, one of the other sons, married Katy Kline, and removed to Ashland. County, Ohio. The other son, Ben, married Ruth Beagle, and removed to a point near Marietta, Ohio. After the close of the Revolutionary War a greater part of the family of Georgo Butler the elder removed to Washington County, Penn. In1812, Abia Butler and his brother-in-law, John Smith, enlisted in the army in the second war with Great Britain, and did service at Erie and on the Canadian frontier, for which service, almost at the close of his life, Mr. Butler was granted a pension. In Washington, Beaver and Allegheny Counties the family of Abia Butler, consisting of ten boys and five girls, were born and grew to maturity. The eldest of this large family was George Butler, who married Mary Ann McCullough, a daughter of John and Eleanor (Herron) McCullough, and to whom were born a family of seven children, namely: Wleanor J.. dohn P., Melissa, George W., Benton, Mary A., and Louisa, the two latter being dead. John P. Butler, the second child, was born, as stated, near Clinton, Allegheny Co., Penn., October 13, L846. In his youth his parents removed to Lawrence County, in the same State. In the common schools of Western Pennsylvania he received his education in the rudiments of learning, and by his assiduity laid the foundation for the future acquisition of knowledge. In attending school. during the winter months and assisting his father on the farm during the farming season, his youth passed until about July 1, 186-4, when, a little over seventeen years of age, he enlisted as a private in Company D, One Hundred and Ninety-third Regiment Pennsylvania Infantry Volunteers, for a period of LOO days. In camp near Baltimore, Mc. he was stricken with disease, and fora period of two months was confined to the hospitals at Baltimore and Chester, Penn.; he recovered sufficiently to return’ to duty, and was honorably discharged with the remainder of his command in October, [S64, after a service of about four months. Retarning home in bad health, he taught school the following winter, and, in the early spring of 1865, his health having been fully restored he re-enlisted in’ Company I, Sixty-seventh Pennsylvania Infantry Volunteers, to serve one year or during the war, and was promoted corporal; with this company he served until the close of the war, being mustered out at Brown's Hill near Washington, D. C., in July, 1865, Tinmediately upon his return home, being not yet nineteen years of age, he came to Sullivan County, Niwk and purchased a small farm. Returning to Pennsylvania SOON after, he induced his parents to remove to Missouri in October of that year, where they resided until the death of his mother at the ave of sixty-five years, on Juno 26, 1886, and where the father still resides. Having induced his parents to remove to Missouri, he attended the Iron City Commercial College at Pittsburgh, Penn., until his money was exhausted, and again taught school during the winter, and returned to Sullivan County, Mo., May 2, 1866. He soon essayed to teach a subscription school in’ the little hamlet of Wintersville, but was compelled to quit on account of ill health. Returning to Milan, he secured employment for a time in the office of H. ‘TL McClanahan, recorder of deeds, and clerk of the circuit court, and from this circumstance his attention was directed to the profession of the law, apon which he resolved to enter. He then began reading law with Judge BR. D. Morrison, pursuing his studies with energy and perseverance. In the meantime he wood and won Maggie Morrison, the youngest daughter of his preceptor, to whom he was married November 4, 1866. The following winter he spent in teaching school at Milan, and reading law, succeeding so well in the latter that in March, 1867, he was daly admitted to tho bar, and licensed to practice in all the courts of record in the State. The profession thus chosen he has followed ever since, meeting with unqualified and deserved success. He is now one of tho most able and successful lawyers of the State, and has the entire confidence and esteem of the community in which he lives. With no capital but brains and energy, his reputation has been made by his own unaided efforts. He is a strong and forcible talker, a great thinker, and a ready writer. In politics he is an unswerving Democrat, and one of the leaders of his party. He has twice sought, and on each occasion nearly secured, the Democratic nomination for Congress in the Second Missouri District, in which the nomination is equivalent to an election, but has never sought political preferment in any other direction. Mr. Butler's wife died November 7, 1873, leaving two children, Georgian and Lou (a son named Leon having died two months prior to his mother). In 1874 he married Miss Delia Payne, a native of Johnson County, Mo. He is a Knight Templar Mason, an ancient member of the K. of H.,and a member of the LO. O. I. and A. O. U. W. fraternities, and his daughters are members of the Methodist Episcopal Church South.

As printed in History of Adair, Sullivan, Putnam and Schuyler Counties, Missouri (1888). See the original pages. Wording is the original; obvious scanning errors have been corrected, and a few may remain.

The 1898 biography (1521 words)

JOHN POLLOCK BUTLER,

JOHN POLLOCK BUTlvER was born in Allegheny County, Pennsylvania, October 13, 1846. When he was nine years old the family removed to Lawrence County, in the same State, settling near Newcastle. His father, George Butler, is still living, at the age of eighty years, near Green City, Sullivan County, Missouri. His mother, whose maiden name was Mary Ann McCullough, was a daughter of John McCuUough, a Scotch-Irishman from the County Antrim, Ireland. He emigrated to America at an early day in this century. Benjamin Butler, the great grandfather of the subject of this sketch, was a soldier in the Revolutionary War, serving throughout on the patriot side. He married Miss Sarah Davis, a lady of Welsh parentage. He sold his farm, on the outskirts of Philadelphia, but was paid in Continental money, which, being repudiated, embarrassed him financially, and to mend his fortunes he moved to a point on the Juniata River, in what is now Huntington County, Pennsylvania. Here Abia, the grandfather of John Pollock Butler, was born, the youngest child of a large family. After battling in the War of 1812, while a youth of eighteen, Abia married Jane Bell, the eldest child of this marriage being George Butler, born in Washington County, Pennsylvania, July 20, 1818. He is the father of the subject of this memoir.

John Pollock Butler was educated in the common schools of Lawrence County, Pennsylvania, and while yet a youth taught two terms in these same schools. He also studied at the Iron City Commercial College, in Pittsburg, and was admitted to practice at Milan, Sullivan County, Missouri, in March, 1867, before he was of age, and was admitted to the bar of the Supreme Court of Missouri, at St. Joseph, at the August term, 1870. In 1876 he was enrolled as a member of the iDar of the United States Circuit and District Courts, at Jefferson City, Missouri. He was enrolled as a member of the bar of the United States Supreme Court, at the October term, 1880. For twelve years he has been the General Attorney of the Quincy, Omaha & Kansas City Railway Company, and for nearly fifteen years attorney for the First National Bank of Milan, Missouri.

Mr. Butler came to Sullivan Coiinty, August 6, 1865, from lyavvrence County, Pennsylvania, and located in Milan, where he has resided ever since. He has been engaged in so many prominent law cases, with constant success, that to enumerate a few of them would be his highest eulogy. In the case of Elijah Smith versus Warren McCullough, involving $40,000 of Sullivan County bonds, which had been subscribed by the county to the St. Joseph & Iowa Railroad Company, the decision of the United States Suj)reme Court, at the October term, 1880, was in favor of McCullough, et al., represented by Mr. Butler. Another was the case of D. H. Crumpacker versus the Chicago, Burlington & Kansas City Railroad Company, and the case of John F. Guffy versus the same defendant. These two cases were heard as one in the State Supreme Court, the Crumpacker case being reversed and the Guffy case affirmed. An appeal was taken in the Guffy case, and the United States Supreme Court sustained the decision of the lower tribunal, which was a decisive victory for Mr. Butler. The chief import of these decisions is that certain railroads in Missouri which had been claiming exemption from taxation under special charters, were made taxpayers and have paid taxes ever since. Here is a notable quotation from Mr. Butler's brief: "The power of taxation is one of those attributes of sovereignty which, under our system of government, is absolutely necessary for the maintenance of the general welfare, and its surrender beyond the legislative power." In a recent noted case in the Siipreme Court of Missouri, that court, in the proceeding then j)ending, declared that it had jurisdiction by reason of its "inherent power," aside from the constitution and the law. His bold, fearless and aggressive nature may well be determined from the character of his reply to this assertion of inherent power, which was that "inherent power lodged elsewhere than in the people, is the instrument by which liberty is denied, and self-government destroyed."

Next to the pride he naturally takes in his legal success, he is famed among his friends in Sullivan County and elsewhere as being the possessor of the largest, most complete and choicest private law library in the State.

During the war he was a volunteer from Pennsylvania, enlisting on July 1, 1864, in Company D, One Hundred and Ninety-second Infantry. Re-enlisting, he became a noncommissioned officer of Company I, of the Sixty-seventh Pennsylvania Infantry Volunteers, being discharged honorably in July, 1865. His political record is not an extensive one, for the reason that he prefers law to politics. Still his fellow-citizens saw fit to make him Elector from the vSecond Missouri District in the Presidential election of 1888, when Harrison defeated Cleveland. He is a Mason, being a member of Seaman Lodge, No. 126; Milan Royal Arch Chapter, of Milan, and of St. Bernard Commandery Knights Templar, of Milan. He is also a member of Milan L,odge, No. 83, I. O. O. F.

He was first married on November 4, 1866, his wife being IMaggie Morrison, youngest daughter of R. D. Morrison. Three children were the offspring of their union, two daughters and one son, the son dying in infancy. Mrs. Butler died November 6, 1873, and on November 7, 1874, he married again, his second wife being Delia B. Payne, by whom he has no children. Georgia, the eldest daughter of the first marriage, is the wife of John N. Shepler, they having two sons. louise, her sister, married D. H. Sholtus, Esq., their children being three sons. Mr. Butler's grandchildren are: Fred Butler Shepler, John George Shepler, John McKinley Sholtus, Edward Turner Sholtus and Robert Ivcon Sholtus.

NE of the promising young lawyers in the State is Myers Downey Campbell, of

\ Kirksville, who was born on a farm in Putnam County, Missouri, November 19, 1869. His father, Melton Campbell, was born near Springfield, Ohio, in 1831, and when a young man came to Fairfield, Iowa, where he met and married Rebecca Downey, the mother of our subject, who was born in Kentucky in 1837, and came of excellent Blue Grass stock. Her family was of Irish derivation, came to this country about the close of the Revolutionary War and settled in Virginia. From Virginia her father emigrated to Kentucky. On the paternal side Mr. Campbell is of Scotch ancestry. His grandfather in this branch was born in Virginia, his parents having emigrated from Scotland. All of Myers D. Campbell's American ancestors were pioneer patriots, and those who lived in that time served faithfully in the Revolutionary War. They were sturdy, brave, upright, honest and religious, and were of that splendid race which, coming from Ireland and Scotland to America, has from Kentucky and Virginia given Missouri so many of the strong and noble men of all professions, but especially to her bench and bar.

Soon after their marriage, Mr. Campbell's parents removed from Fairfield, Iowa, to Putnam County, Missouri, where the son was born. The latter was educated in the public schools of Putnam County, and when he had completed his studies there, he entered the Missouri State Normal at Kirksville. When he had completed the course at the Normal, he at once took up the study of law, in the office of Judge Andrew Ellison, than whom a better instructor could not have been found. On completing his studies he was admitted to the bar, at Lancaster, Missouri, by Judge Andrew Ellison, his preceptor. May 14, 1889. He at once opened an office at Kirksville and began practice, and has won a most satisfactory degree of success, considering the short time he has followed his profession. During the earlier years he occupied an office alone, but he recently formed a partnership with W. D. Goode, and that agreement is still operative, under the firm style of Campbell & Goode.

In the year following his admission, Mr. Campbell's first official honor came, in the form of an election to the City Attorneyship of Kirksville. In 1892 he was elected Prosecuting Attorney of Adair County, an event that signally testified to the high esteem in which he is held, as v/hen he was elected the county was Republican by several hundred majority, and Mr. Campbell is of opposite political faith. Mr. Campbell is at the present time attorney for the First International Bank, of Kirksville, of Dr. A. T. Still's Infirmary and American School of Osteopathy, and is interested in and a director of the Campbell Banking Company, at Xenia, Missouri. He is a member of the Odd Fellows' Society and of the Knights of Pythias, and has held about all the offices in the Kirksville lodge of the former order.

Mr. Campbell was married September 12, 1894, to Miss Edith E., daughter of J. N. McClanahan, of Corydon, Iowa. They have one child, a boy named John M., aged two years.

As printed in The history of the bench and bar of Missouri : With reminiscences of the prominent lawyers of the past, and a record of the law's leaders of the present (1898). See the original pages. Wording is the original; obvious scanning errors have been corrected, and a few may remain.

Connected people

Others in these records

Their biographies name John P. Butler: William H. Taylor Charles W. Thomas (b. 1811)

Done-for-you research

Descended from John P. Butler?

The printed record stops around 1888. We trace your line from there down to you, with every source cited.

See packages & start   or get a free written plan first

Keep exploring
Have your own family tree?

We turn the trees people have already built into real hardcover books, written oldest generation to newest, with every fact sourced. We also check key facts and tie up loose ends.